The Case of Aleah Beckerle timeline: From her disappearance to the trial of Terrence Roach

News

Nearly two years ago, Aleah Beckerle disappeared from her home and sparked an eight-month search for her that would eventually come to a close in March of 2017.

Aleah’s disappearance

Beckerle, a 19-year-old with severe disabilities who had to use a wheel chair, was first reported missing on July 17, 2016.

A 911 call from Aleah’s house captured the raw emotion the Beckerle family had the moment they saw her wheelchair beside her bed and nothing but sheets where she once laid.

The call was made by Aleah’s sister, who eventually handed the phone to her mother, Cara Beckerle.

“They came into my house and took my disabled daughter,” Cara said. “She needs a wheelchair and they just took her.”

Click here to hear the 911 call from the night she went missing.

The search for Aleah

For eight months, many wondered where Aleah was.

Within four days of the disappearance, search groups had been organized, a $1,000 reward was issued, and Evansville police had declared the mysterious disappearance a criminal investigation with assistance from the FBI.

False confession beating

In August of 2016, Evansville police issued a warrant at the Beckerle house for electronic devices.

However, in a twist, detectives were led to something else.

Aleah’s cousin, Donna Robertson; Donna’s partner, Debra Wollner; and James Wilson Jr. were all arrested and charged with beating a man into making a false confession in Aleah’s disappearance.

Wilson was sentenced to one year in jail in November of 2016, while Wollner and Robertson were sentenced to three years of house arrest in March of 2017.

Aleah’s mother speaks

On August 25, 2016, Aleah’s mother Cara spoke with Eyewitness News about her daughter’s disappearance.

“This was a planned kidnapping,” she said. “It’s not random. It was planned, but if you’re just scared now – it’s okay. Just bring her back. Please bring Aleah back.”

Weinbach and I-69 search

In September of 2016, Evansville police searched the area of Weinbach and I-69 in relation to the disappearance. However, animal bones were discovered and the findings were not related to Aleah’s case.

Landfill search

On September 26, 2016, the search expanded to a Pike County landfill.

A federal search warrant was served at the Advanced Disposal Blackfoot Landfill in Pike County.

The search concluded on October 25 with nothing significant discovered.

For the next several months, the search parties dwindled but the searching continued.

Aleah’s body is found

On March 27, 2017, everything changed.

Evansville police said a decomposed body was discovered inside a vacant home on South Bedford Ave.

Two days after the body was found, it was identified as Aleah Beckerle.

Read more: Affidavit Sheds Light on Aleah Beckerle’s Disappearance, Death

Terrence Roach arrested

Then, two days after the body was identified, Terrence Roach was arrested in connection with the case. Terrence is the son of Cara Beckerle’s former boyfriend, DeMarco Roach.

The day of the arrest, Terrence’s stepfather shared his reaction, saying, “This **** is crazy because I asked him a long time ago when she came up missing. This **** is so weird. It just seems like a damn nightmare.”

The house on South Bedford Ave. where the remains were discovered was right next door to the house where Terrence Roach stayed.

Roach did have a prior record before his arrest in connection with the Beckerle case.

Eyewitness News obtained documents in 2017 showing he had felony charges dating back to 2013, not connected to the case of Aleah Beckerle.

In 2013, he pleaded guilty to criminal recklessness involving serious bodily injury.

In 2014, he pleaded guilty to attempted robbery resulting in bodily injury.

Verdict reached in Roach trial

During Roach’s trial in May of 2018, the jury found him not guilty of three counts of murder, burglary, and kidnapping.

However, the jury did find him guilty on charges of criminal confinement and abuse of a corpse.

The verdict came down just before 1:00 a.m. on Thursday.

The jury deliberated for nearly 11 hours.

The Beckerle family was left broken as the verdict came down. Anger boiled over as family members stood and yelled in the courtroom after court adjourned.

Aleah’s grandmother, Lydia Larue, exclusively shared her feelings with Eyewitness News before the verdict.

“It was very hard. It was hard to sit there, not scream, not cry, get up and stop my feet. It was hard and hard to sit there in the same room as him, sometimes just twelve feet away from me. This was a baby, she was disabled, she couldn’t run away, she could not scream out, she couldn’t fight him and he did some horrible things to her.”

Watch the full interview with Larue here:

For the latest breaking news and stories from across the Tri-State, follow Eyewitness News on Facebook and Twitter.

(This story was originally published May 24, 2018)

Copyright 2019 Nexstar Broadcasting, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Trending Stories